|
|
||||||||
Paris Descartes University, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris, Thoracic Surgery Department, Georges Pompidou European Hospital, Paris, France
Accepted for publication April 1, 2009.
* Address correspondence to Dr Riquet, Thoracic Surgery Department, Georges Pompidou European Hospital, 20 rue Leblanc, Paris, 75015, France (Email: marc.riquet{at}egp.aphp.fr).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: Among 565 patients with mediastinal lymph node enlargement, 37 had a history of extrathoracic carcinoma. The enlargement consisted in HMLNMs in 26 (15 men, 11 women), with a mean age of 57.6 (range 19-78) years. Surgical procedures were reviewed.
Results: Diagnostic procedures, comprising mediastinoscopy in 9, anterior mediastinotomy in 2, and video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) in 4, were performed mainly because of unresectability due to diffuse and bilateral HMLNMs. Cancer location was breast in 6, kidney or prostate in 2 each, and bladder, rectum, testis, melanoma, and larynx in 1 each. Median survival was 21 months. Resection was performed in 11 patients, comprising posterolateral thoracotomy in 6, muscle sparing thoracotomy in 2, and VATS in 3. Seventeen involved LN stations were removed; of these, primary were kidney in 3, testis or thyroid in 2 each, and larynx, nasopharynx, and intestinum in 1 each. Five-year survival was 41.6% (median, 45 months).
Conclusions: HMLNMs of extrathoracic carcinoma may be isolated, probably in the context of a particular lymphatic mode of spread. Our experience demonstrates that operation is mainly diagnostic but resection may safely achieve local control of the disease and deserves being advocated in patients with isolated and resectable HMLNMs.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Patients and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In the remaining 26 patients (15 men, 11 women), the mediastinal HMLNMs were from an extrathoracic malignancy and form the basis of our study. The patients were a mean age of 57.6 ± 15.3 years (range, 19 to 78 years). The HMLNMs were synchronous in 2 patients and metachronous in 24, and the mean interval between both events was 5.5 ± 5.7 years (range, 1 to 24 years).
Our Institutional Review Board approved this study and waived the requirement for patient consent. All medical charts were reviewed, and a thorough workup included bone scintigraphy, brain and abdominal computed tomography imaging, and more recently, positron-emission tomography tomodensitometric (PET-TDM) imaging, to rule out distant metastases or local recurrence, or both, of the previously resected extrathoracic carcinoma. Diagnostic and therapeutic surgical procedures were analyzed. The postoperative course was uneventful. Involved LN stations were classified according to Mountain and Dresler [6].
Follow-up information was obtained from the hospital case records, from a questionnaire completed by the local chest physician or general practitioner, or from death certificates. The main outcome was the overall survival, defined as the time interval between the date of operation and the date of death or the last follow-up visit for censored patients. No patient was lost to follow-up. Actuarial survival curves were estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method. Statistical comparisons between survival distributions were made using the log-rank test. The statistical software used for the analysis was SEM (Anticancer Centre Jean Perrin, Clermont-Ferrand, France) [7].
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mahon and Libshitz [2] analyzed 50 mediastinal metastases of infradiaphragmatic malignancies on computed tomodensitography, a technique allowing a better visualization of all nodal groups in the mediastinum. None of the HMLNMs were isolated, and all were associated with other distant metastases, of which 29 (58%) were located in the lungs. Several LN stations were commonly involved, and one single station was involved in only 6%. Besides a majority of genitourinary malignancies (kidney, 25; testis, 7; prostate, 4; ovary, 3; bladder, 2), they also observed metastases from carcinoma of the colon or rectum in 6 and stomach in 3. However, Mahon and Libshitz [2] could not draw any conclusion about the frequency of mediastinal metastases among patients with gastrointestinal carcinomas. This information was provided by Libson and colleagues [8], who reported 12 cases in 1194 patients (1%) with carcinomas of the stomach, pancreas, colon, and rectum.
Mediastinal metastases from tumors of the head and neck are also infrequent. Of 779 patients with head and neck cancer, 96 (12.3%) were found clinically or at autopsy to have distant metastases, and mediastinal metastases were detected in 5 (0.6%) [9]. However, they are probably slightly more frequent in case of carcinoma of the nasopharynx [10] and may be observed in 2% to 9% of patients with thyroid carcinoma [11, 12].
Whatever the primary cancer, nodal or systemic metastases are common at distant sites by the time the spread to the mediastinum is apparent clinically [1, 2, 8, 10], and mediastinal involvement indicates an advanced stage of the disease, commonly ruling out surgical resection in view of a cure. For that reason, the rare isolated HMLNMs are considered to share the same poor prognostic value and their possible resectability is all the more overlooked because the procedure seems aggressive. Furthermore, the diagnosis is commonly assessed by cervical mediastinoscopy in case of mediastinal lymphadenopathy, and metastases from extrathoracic malignancies represent less than 2% of the patients (11 of 700) [13]. In our series, the 37 patients accounted for only 6% of the patients who underwent a diagnostic surgical procedure for isolated mediastinal LN during the same period of time in our department.
Nowadays, surgical intervention is progressively being replaced by EUS-FNA-based differential cytodiagnostics for establishing the diagnosis of mediastinal LN disease. In a series of 153 patients, 52 had a history of cancer that was extrathoracic in 37 patients, and a mediastinal recurrence was observed in 12 (32.4%) [4]. Our series had a similar number of patients and recurrence was diagnosed in 26 (70.3%), which is twice as frequent. This frequency could have been biased by the specificity of our department, but the mediastinal recurrence rate was 55% in another series of 20 patients [14]: EUS-FNA was negative in 8 patients and surgical intervention disclosed 5 more positive cases, which raises the rate of recurrences to 80%. Those results led to the conclusion that surgical intervention, a procedure with substantial risk of complications and limited therapeutic benefits, may be avoided in 60% of patients [14].
The extrathoracic malignancies harboring HMLNMs may be numerous and various. Because policy is to perform a lymphadenectomy when HMLNMs are isolated and deemed resectable, we were able to document 11 patients with 6 different extrathoracic primary cancers, confirming the safety and the effectiveness of the procedure and the place of surgical intervention for HMLNMs.
The HMLNMs from genitourinary malignancies appeared the most frequent, as reported in the literature [1, 2]. Hilar LN metastasis presenting as a recurrence after nephrectomy for cancer was first reported in 1976 [15]. Among a few more HMLNMs cases reported thereafter, 3 were treated by resection [16–18], and 1 patient is known to have survived 3 years [16]. One of our patients survived 45 months (Table 2). A recent series of 9 patients demonstrated a median survival of 3.2 years after resection, significantly extending survival compared with survival of other patients with stage IV disease from the same institution [19]. Those results are encouraging and support that resection should be considered an important component of treating patients with renal cell carcinoma who have asynchronous HMLNMs [19].
Nonseminatous germ cell tumors of testicular origin metastasize to the retroperitoneum LN. They may subsequently metastasize to contiguous mediastinal lymphatics. Cisplatin-based chemotherapy alone suffices for a cure for most patients with supradiaphragmatic metastases. In 10% to 20% of testicular nonseminatous germ cell tumors with presentation or subsequent development of supradiaphragmatic metastases, at least one thoracic surgical procedure, in the form of either of mediastinal dissection or pulmonary metastasectomy, was required to remove persistent radiographic abnormalities after chemotherapy [20].
Kesler and colleagues [20] reviewed 268 patients who required at least one procedure to remove residual mediastinal disease, and 98 (36.6%) manifested mediastinal disease during or after chemotherapy. Retroperitoneal LN dissection was performed in 89.2% of patients and was in conjunction with thoracic surgical procedures in 31.9%. Long-term survival was good to excellent. The rate of isolated HMLNM was not furnished, and all metastases were observed during the immediate follow-up of the patients. Late disease occurrence such as we observed is rare and also requires removal not only to assess the diagnosis but also to ensure a cure and to prevent the evolution toward a mediastinal growing teratoma syndrome, a phenomenon whereby germ cell tumors enlarge after chemotherapy [21].
All the other genitourinary malignancies can metastasize to the hilar or mediastinal LNs, and primary cancers from the bladder [1, 2, 4, 14], cervix and corpus uteri [1, 4, 14], ovary [1, 2], breast [1, 4, 13], and prostate [22] have been reported. However, the HMLNMs presentation rarely offers an opportunity for resection. Thoracic metastases from breast cancer do not usually present as isolated HMLNM [23, 24], or are unresectable, as we observed in 6 patients; however, the selected patient we had the opportunity to treat by resection is still disease-free 5 years later, thus supporting the idea of resection. Cancers of the uterus may recur as isolated HMLNMs. Kawaguchi and colleagues [3] reported a patient who underwent a radical hysterectomy for a cervical cancer of the uterus, a left hilar and mediastinal lymphadenectomy for intrathoracic recurrence 26 months later, and again a right hilar lymphadenectomy 25 months after that. She eventually died of the disease 8 months after the second thoracotomy because of retroperitoneal recurrence, almost a 5-year survival.
The infradiaphragmatic malignancies that do not involve the genitourinary tract are not so frequently responsible for HMLNMs [1, 2]. The small-intestine neuroendocrine tumor of which we operated on as a HMLNM was of low-grade malignancy. The most frequently concerned gastrointestinal carcinomas are the colon carcinomas [8], and 2 patients treated by HMLNMs resection were reported [3, 25]. Both patients also underwent intervention for liver metastases, and it is worth stressing that 1 patient was disease-free 3 years after the thoracotomy [3].
We performed three procedures for isolated HMLNM from head and neck cancers. In 2 patients the resection was after a previous laryngectomy. The resection was incomplete in 1 patient because postradiation fibrosis rendered further dissection impossible, and the mediastinal LN capsula was ruptured in the other patient. In fact, previous radiation therapy that precluded new irradiation was one of the main reasons prompting the surgical resection in these 3 patients. The third patient, with former nasopharynx cancer, is still alive disease-free more than 1 year after complete resection.
Mediastinal dissection is rather uncommon in case of thyroid carcinoma but may be performed in four circumstances: at the time of thyroidectomy and conservative bilateral neck dissection [11], on the occasion of revision of the initial dissection for a recurrence [11], in association with lung metastasectomy [26], and more rarely as isolated HMLNM, as we performed twice. Macroscopic locoregional LN metastases from thyroid cancer should be first dealt with surgically, if technically feasible, because their extirpation can be occasionally curative [27] or can render subsequent radioactive iodine administrations for residual disease more efficacious [26]. However, the prognosis is generally poor at this stage of the disease.
The route and mechanism of extension of LN metastases into the thorax from extrathoracic malignancies is not completely understood. The metastases from primary sites in the head and neck are postulated to result from spread from the neck to mediastinal LNs along lymphatic vessels described by Rouvière [28], the anterior or jugular lymphatic chain communicating with the anterior mediastinal LN [1]. In differentiated thyroid carcinoma, HMLNM is significantly correlated with contralateral cervical LN metastases, but metastasis to the mediastinal region directly from the primary tumor was also demonstrated [29]. In medullary thyroid carcinoma, extrathyroidal extension, and not involvement of contralateral cervicolateral LN, is a predictor of HMLNM [12]. In laryngeal carcinoma, mediastinal LN involvement more often accompanies stomal recurrence [30], which was not the case in both our patients.
In case of infradiaphragmatic malignancy, the spread to the mediastinum occurs from the thoracic duct. In effect, the lymphatics from the pelvis and abdomen drain into the thoracic duct, which also receives tributaries from the intrathoracic organs and their regional LN basins within the mediastinum [31]. Retrograde flow from the thoracic duct into the paratracheal and bronchopulmonary LN may ensue through a lymphatic vessel with incompetent valves, a dysfunction reported to occur in 5% to 14% of lymphatic vessels by McLoud and colleagues [1].
In genitourinary carcinomas, the demonstration is easily available. The renal lymphatics drain into the paraaortic LN groups, and, further on, consistently terminate into the thoracic duct, sometimes directly without crossing through any LN [32]. They mainly contribute to the thoracic duct origin because of this particular anatomy and of the large quantity of lymph they generate [32]. The lymphatics from the pelvis and other genitourinary neoplasms connect to the same paraaortic LN [1, 2, 28] and thus follow the same route [8], but the quantity of lymph is smaller. However, this special layout probably explains the reason why HMLNMs from those organs are the most frequent. In instances of gastrointestinal carcinomas, the lymphatic drainage also ultimately connects to the paraaortic nodes, but the juxtaorgans mesenteric LN amount is longer acting as a dam reservoir.
Other anecdotal and marginal explanations have been provided. Rino and colleagues [33] incidentally demonstrated a route from the paraaortic LN through the diaphragm, visible on a lymphangiogram performed during a gastrectomy in a patient with a gastric cancer, but without nodal involvement. In the colonic cases of Libson and colleagues [8], mediastinal metastases were seen after, or coincidentally with, the appearance of liver metastases. The authors reported two main lymph streams from the liver, one through the celiac nodes and the other through the thorax to the mediastinal nodes of both sides: metastatic spread to the liver could, in this manner, be followed by antegrade seeding to the mediastinal LNs [8].
To conclude, HMLNM from an extrathoracic carcinoma is infrequent but may present in isolated patients, probably in the context of a particular lymphatic mode of spread. In our experience, corroborating some sparse results reported in the literature, resection could be done safely and proved useful to achieve local control of the disease as well as beneficial to some selected patients. We therefore suggest that surgical intervention should not only be considered for diagnosis in all patients but also more ambitiously discussed in cases of isolated and resectable HMLNMs.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Related Article
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Sano, T. Murakawa, T. Morota, and J. Nakajima Resection of a Posterior Mediastinal Metastasis of Colon Cancer Ann. Thorac. Surg., July 1, 2011; 92(1): 353 - 354. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Hoover Invited Commentary Ann. Thorac. Surg., July 1, 2009; 88(1): 205 - 205. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |