|
|
||||||||
Ann Thorac Surg 2007;84:1250-1255
© 2007 The Society of Thoracic Surgeons
a The International Heart Institute of Montana Foundation at Saint Patrick Hospital and Health Sciences Center, The University of Montana, Missoula, Montana
b Department of Mathematics, The University of Montana, Missoula, Montana
Accepted for publication May 1, 2007.
* Address correspondence to Dr Duran, The International Heart Institute of Montana Foundation, 500 W Broadway, Ste 350, Missoula, MT 59802 (Email: duran{at}saintpatrick.org).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: The basal chordae were defined as the chordae that arise from the papillary muscles and insert into the ventricular aspect of the leaflets.
Results: All leaflet insertions of the basal chordae were close to the annulus, except at the anterior mitral leaflet, where insertion was at the junction of the smooth and rough zones. The number of basal chordae was 24.6 ± 4.21 in the porcine, 19.7 ± 2.90 in ovine, and 18.81 ± 3.54 in the human hearts. At least two anterior basal chordae were present in each half of the anterior leaflet in 70% of ovine and porcine and in 100% of human hearts. At least two basal chordae were present in each half of the middle scallop of the posterior mitral leaflet in 80% of ovine, 70% of porcine, and 63.6% of humans. Among them, only the two principal or strut chordae were identified as the longest and thickest.
Conclusions: The basal chordae of the mitral valve follow a definite pattern in each of the three species studied. A new and logical terminology that should facilitate identification of specific basal chordae is suggested.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Material and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Terminology
The different components of the mitral valve were classified according to the terminology described by Kumar and colleagues [4], which is familiar to surgeons and echocardiographers [5] (Fig 1). This terminology was based on the principle that the mitral valve is basically a paired structure determined by its two papillary muscles.
|
The other half of the anterior leaflet, commissure, and posteromedial scallop supported by the posterior papillary muscle (called "M2") were identified as A2, C2, and P2. Because it is supported by chordae from both papillary muscles (M1 and M2), the posterior middle scallop (PM), was divided into PM1 and PM2. The two trigones were identified as T1 for the left and T2 for the right.
Similar with previously published classifications, the mitral chordae were divided into marginal (first order) when inserted into the leaflets free edge and basal (second order) when inserted into the ventricular aspect of the body of the leaflets [6–8]. All chordae were identified by their insertion into the anterior leaflet (A1 and A2) and posterior mitral leaflet (P1, PM1, PM2, and P2). The two constant and thick anterior (AS) and posterior (PS) strut chordae were identified as AS1 and AS2 for the anterior and PS1 and PS2 for the posterior. The other basal chordae located lateral to the AS and PS were termed AB1 and AB2 for the anterior, and PMB1 and PMB2 for the middle scallop of the posterior leaflet (Fig 2 and Fig 3). For the purpose of this study, pure (or marginal) basal chordae were defined as those with no other type of chordae arising from them; they were labeled "mixed" when the chordae had both basal and marginal branches.
|
|
The number, distribution, length, and thickness of all anterior and posterior basal chordae were measured. The origin from each papillary muscle was recorded as low, middle, or high according to whether the basal chorda originated at the base, body, or tip of the papillary muscle. Photographs and drawings were taken of each specimen.
All data are reported as mean ± the standard deviation. Data were compared using a t test for paired observations, with the level of significance set at p < 0.05 for statistical comparison within a species. Interspecies comparisons of basal chorda number were done using analysis of variance (ANOVA), with Bonferroni correction using XLSTAT 2007 software (Addinsoft SARL, Paris, France).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
The leaflet insertion of the basal chordae into the undersurface of the anterior leaflet was at the junction of the smooth and rough zones (Fig 2). The anterior leaflet smooth zone height varied considerably between individual valves: mean 10.78 ± 3.20 mm in porcine (range, 5 to 15.88 mm); 6.46 ± 1.66 mm in ovine (range, 5 to 9.7 mm), and 10.22 mm ± 1.71 in humans (range, 6.77 to 12.01 mm). The leaflet insertion of the basal chordae into the posterior leaflet and commissural areas was always close to the annulus in all three species (Fig 3). In fact, except for the anterior leaflet, all basal chordae were inserted around the annulus (Fig 4).
|
The insertion of the basal chordae into the papillary muscles was semicircular. The insertion of both anterior strut chordae (AS1 and AS2) into the papillary muscles was the lowest of all chordal insertions in 100% of the porcine and ovine hearts. In humans, the AS1 insertion was the lowest in only 63.64% of the hearts and AS2 in 90.91%. In these hearts, the chorda inserted at the lowest point of the papillary muscle was a very thin marginal chorda.
The PS insertions showed a greater variability in their papillary muscle insertion. In the porcine heart, PS1 and PS2 were inserted at the highest point of both papillary muscles (M1 and M2) in 30% of the cases. In the ovine heart, PS1 insertion was the highest in 40% and PS2 in 30%. In humans, the PS chordae were always inserted in an intermediate position of both papillary muscles and never at the lowest point of the papillary muscles in all hearts.
The AS and PS lengths and thicknesses are presented in Tables 2 and 3.
Although the lengths of the anterior and posterior basal chordae were significantly different in the ovine hearts, no statistical difference was found in the human and porcine hearts. Again, the lengths of the AS and PS were different in the porcine (p < 0.0005) and ovine (p < 0.0005) hearts but not in human hearts. No significant differences were found between the lengths of AS1 and AS2 and PS1 and PS2 in all three species.
|
|
Pattern of Distribution of the Basal Chords
Evaluation of the basal chorda distribution showed that at least two chordae (ie, one strut and its adjacent basal chorda) were present in each half of the anterior leaflet in 70% of porcine and ovine (7/10) and in 100% of human hearts (11/11). At least two basal chordae were present in each half of the middle scallop of the posterior leaflet in 70% of porcine (7/10), 80% of ovine (8/10), and 63.63% of humans hearts (7/11).
Marginal or rough zone chordae usually arose from the basal chordae. The marginal and corresponding basal chordae formed triangular structures found all around the mitral valve. Pure marginal chordae (ie, arising directly from a papillary muscle without connection with basal chordae) were infrequent (1 to 6 per valve).
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In a subsequent anatomic study, we confirmed the individuality of these four strut chordae [4]. Because of their thickness and strategic location, we postulated that they must be essential in maintaining the geometry of the mitral valve and probably of the left ventricle. Contrary to "strut," which means a structure designed to resist compression, we suggest they should be called "stay" chordae, which implies a support or steadying function [14]. Lomholt and colleagues [15] have shown in a sheep model that the anterior stay chordae sustain approximately three times more tension than the corresponding marginal chordae.
Increasing evidence is now available on the importance of these stay chordae. Recent experimental and clinical studies have shown their role in the genesis of functional ischemic mitral regurgitation [1–3]. The lateral and apical displacement of the ischemic posterior papillary muscle pulls the anterior leaflet downward, making the valve incompetent. The inextensible anterior stay chordae that connect the papillary muscle to the anterior leaflet are responsible for this tenting effect. A logical consequence of this mechanism led Messas and colleagues [16] to suggest cutting the anterior stay chordae as a surgical treatment of ischemic regurgitation. However, further experimental studies have questioned the wisdom of this technique because of the negative effect it might have on left ventricular function [17, 18].
These facts stimulated the present work, which was primarily designed to obtain a detailed knowledge of the mitral basal chordae in ovine, porcine, and human hearts. These species were selected because most experimental studies have been performed in ovine and porcine models expecting that the results could be transferred to the human heart. The present study shows that the number of basal chordae in the human was similar to the ovine but not the porcine valves. Also, although the origin of the anterior stay chordae in the papillary muscles was the lowest in the ovine and porcine hearts, it was only in 77.30% of the human specimens. From a clinical point of view, this easily identified landmark, although useful in the animal, is unreliable in the human heart. A more reliable reference point to identify the anterior and posterior stay chordae is their location as the most medial of all basal chordae in 100% of all three species. This method of identification can easily be done through a standard atriotomy.
The significant difference in the height of the rough and smooth zones of the anterior mitral leaflet within the same species (10 mm in porcine and 5 mm in ovine and human hearts) should alert the surgeon when performing an anterior leaflet basal incision to increase or reduce its area [20, 21]. This incision should not inadvertently section the stay chordae. It is also interesting that although the length of the anterior and posterior stay chordae is similar in the humans, the posterior stay chordae were shorter than the anterior in the ovine and porcine specimens. This geometric difference, which might be due to humans being bipedal, must be taken into consideration when data from animal studies are assumed to apply to human subjects.
In all cases, the anterior stay chordae were thicker than the posterior. This finding suggests that the anterior stay chordae sustain higher tension during the cardiac cycle. We have shown in an acute sheep model that the sectioning of these two anterior stay chordae induced an immediate increase in the aorta-mitral angle formed by the aortic and mitral annulus planes [22]. The apex of this angle is directly connected to the anterior stay chordae through the aortic curtain. Integrity of the hearts basal plane has been shown to be essential for left ventricular pumping action [20].
Soon after initiating the present anatomic study, we were overwhelmed by the difficulty in describing our findings. The classic descriptions of the mitral basal chordae were limited to mentioning their presence in the anterior and posterior leaflets and of two thicker anterior strut or principal chordae. A more precise terminology was obviously needed.
Application of Carpentiers well-known terminology [23] was difficult because it is based on three anterior (A1, A2, A3) and three posterior (P1, P2, P3) leaflet areas. This is a very simple and practical classification for the surgeon when dealing at the leaflet level but insufficient when attempting to describe all marginal and basal chordae. For instance, the anterior marginal and basal chordae cannot be classified into three groups (A1, A2, or A3) because anatomically there are clearly two groups defined by their papillary muscle origin. Similarly, the chordae of the posterior middle scallop (P2) are separated into two groups according to their origin from two papillary muscles. A more rational method is to classify all chordae according to their papillary muscle origin. This method considers the mitral valve as being formed by two symmetrical hemivalves supported by two papillary muscles.
It is hoped that this anatomic study of the basal chordae will increase the awareness of their importance, question the concept of their section as innocuous, and stimulate new mitral valve repair techniques.
The main limitation of this study is the small number of specimens. In addition, the measurements were performed under static, nonphysiologic conditions in an excised heart. However, because of the care undertaken to avoid deformations, the identification and location of the different chordae should not have been affected. Of more concern is the method used to measure their length and thickness with calipers. Aware of the possibility of interoperator error with this limitation, all measurements were performed by a single observer. Comparison between species in terms of difference in lengths and thickness of the basal chordae cannot be made because of the differences in weights of the hearts. Also the number and location of the chordae within a species should not be age-dependent.
This study addresses a largely ignored anatomic component of the mitral valve. We present information on the presence, type, and location of the different basal chordae and in particular the anterior and posterior strut chordae. This nomenclature for the basal chordae will facilitate the recording of findings as well as new chordal surgical procedures. It is hoped that this effort will bring nearer the biblical statement that "Now the whole earth had one language and a common speech" (Genesis 11:1–1).
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Related Article
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. F. Wenk, Z. Zhang, G. Cheng, D. Malhotra, G. Acevedo-Bolton, M. Burger, T. Suzuki, D. A. Saloner, A. W. Wallace, J. M. Guccione, et al. First Finite Element Model of the Left Ventricle With Mitral Valve: Insights Into Ischemic Mitral Regurgitation Ann. Thorac. Surg., May 1, 2010; 89(5): 1546 - 1553. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Z. Makhija and J. Desai Early and mid-term functional and survival benefits in ischaemic versus degenerative mitral valve repair using Duran flexible ring: a single surgeon series Interact CardioVasc Thorac Surg, September 1, 2009; 9(3): 471 - 475. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. H. Gorman III Invited commentary Ann. Thorac. Surg., October 1, 2007; 84(4): 1255 - 1255. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |