|
|
||||||||
Ann Thorac Surg 2007;83:1431-1436
© 2007 The Society of Thoracic Surgeons
Department of Surgery, Childrens Hospital, Omaha, Nebraska
Accepted for publication October 3, 2006.
* Address correspondence to Dr Fenton, 14805 Maydale Ct, Silver Spring, MD 20905 (Email: kathleennf{at}msn.com).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: Cerebral oxygen saturation was continuously recorded intraoperatively in 34 infants and children undergoing palliative surgery on cardiopulmonary bypass for single ventricle congenital heart defects and in a control group of 12 neonates with ductus-dependent circulation undergoing complete repair. Saturations were correlated with the patients stage and outcome.
Results: Baseline ScO 2 was 61% in single ventricle neonates (group P1, n = 10), 55% in neonates undergoing repair (group R), 42% in infants undergoing stage 2 palliation (group P2, n = 6), and 70% in children undergoing Fontan (group P3, n = 14). Baseline was lowest (41%) in infants undergoing interstage operations (group I, n = 4). After bypass, there was a significant improvement in ScO 2 to 53% in group P2 infants (p = 0.04); there were no significant changes in the other groups. By the end of the operation, there was a significant decrease in ScO 2 to 48% in group P1 (p = 0.001), with other groups unchanged from baseline. There were five perioperative deaths. Cerebral oxygen saturation at the conclusion of surgery was lower in children who died (38% versus 61%, p = 0.01).
Conclusions: In children with single ventricle physiology, ScO 2 decreases after initial palliation, remains low before second-stage palliation, but is normal before and after the Fontan. This has implications for perioperative mortality, neurologic injury, and potentially for interim mortality. Low postoperative ScO 2 predicts perioperative mortality.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Intraoperative monitoring of the brain has recently been introduced in an effort to detect and correct problems in the operating room. Near-infrared spectroscopy measures the concentrations of oxygenated and deoxygenated hemoglobin and calculates an index of cerebral oxygen saturation (ScO 2). The measurement reflects approximately 75% to 85% cerebral venous blood and has been correlated with jugular vein saturation [3, 4]. The basic principles behind this monitoring technique have been well outlined elsewhere (57). Neurologic monitoring during cardiac surgery allows detection and correction of abnormalities in adults [1, 6,8] and children [1, 9], with resultant improvement in outcomes.
Factors other than the adverse effects of surgery may contribute to abnormal neurologic outcome in a significant number of children. Congenital heart defects are common in patients with genetic disorders that are also associated with neurologic abnormality, such as Trisomy 21, Trisomy 18, DiGeorge syndrome, and others.
Other patients with congenital heart defects, but without a recognizable syndrome, also have a higher incidence of CNS malformations. For example, brain abnormalities are associated with coarctation of the aorta, and as many as 30% of infants with hypoplastic left heart syndrome may have brain dysgenesis [1]. Cranial ultrasound images have been shown to be abnormal in 42% of neonates with major congenital heart defects [10]. Cerebral blood flow has also recently been demonstrated to be low preoperatively in infants with congenital heart disease, which correlates with some abnormalities seen on ultrasound images [10]. Finally, although most newborns presenting for cardiac surgery may appear normal to their cardiologists and cardiac surgeons, a careful neurobehavioral evaluation can often identify significant abnormalities, including hypotonia, hypertonia, poor state regulation, and feeding difficulties in more than half [11].
Measurement of cerebral oxygen saturation, in addition to detecting and allowing correction of intraoperative problems, may also have prognostic implications. We [12], and others [2], have recently demonstrated that baseline ScO 2 is related to the cardiac physiology in children undergoing surgery for congenital heart defects. Low baseline ScO 2 was associated with leftright shunt physiology and was a strong predictor of perioperative death in our patient population. Measurement and optimization of ScO 2 may improve outcomes for our highest-risk group of patients, those undergoing staged palliation for single ventricle defects. We hypothesized that ScO 2, a surrogate marker for the adequacy of cerebral (and therefore systemic) perfusion in this patient population, would improve as palliation is accomplished.
| Patients and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Baseline ScO 2 was recorded in the operating room before the induction of anesthesia. Because of the size of the sensors relative to the size of the infants forehead, we commonly used only one sensor to measure ScO 2 in infants. The correlation between the two hemispheres in children has been investigated [5]. Because cerebral injury in children is most commonly flow-related, rather than embolic as in adults, we, and others, consider single sensor monitoring to be appropriate. In cases where bihemispheric monitoring was done, we arbitrarily chose to use the value from the right side for the purposes of this study. Because the ScO 2 was continuously recorded, we selected specific time points during the surgery to sample data for analysis. These were noted on the record in the operating room and were consistent across patient groups.
Intraoperative data were recorded into a database prospectively. Preoperative and postoperative data were collected from the patients medical records retrospectively. Data were also collected and analyzed for a control group of 12 consecutive newborns with ductus-dependent physiology who underwent complete biventricular repair during the same time period.
Neonates with ductus-dependent circulation were managed with prostaglandin infusion, assessment, and stabilization, followed by repair or palliation at several days of age. The exceptions were 2 infants with infradiaphragmatic total anomalous pulmonary venous connection who were repaired within 24 hours of diagnosis.
Selective cerebral perfusion was routinely used in infants undergoing arch reconstruction. Modified ultrafiltration was routinely used after separation from CPB.
Infants with single ventricle anatomy underwent stage 2 palliation electively at age 3 to 6 months. Completion Fontan was accomplished at 2 to 4 years of age. All children undergoing elective stage 2 or stage 3 palliation had cardiac catheterization before surgery and had pulmonary vascular resistance that was judged by the cardiologist and the surgeon to be satisfactory. The timing of stage 2 and stage 3 palliation was determined by the patients systemic oxygen saturation and by the preference of the family and referring cardiologist. An effort made to avoid surgery in the winter months, when possible.
We began using the cerebral oximeter in May 2002, at first sporadically and then routinely for all cardiac procedures. The oximeter was used as a clinical tool in the operating room, and thus, efforts were made to optimize cerebral saturation by adjustments in anesthetic and perfusion techniques, transfusion if indicated, and correction of other identifiable problems.
Patient demographic data were characterized by simple descriptive statistics, including range, mean, and median. Intraoperative cerebral saturation results were compared with baseline in each group using a Student t test. A Student t test was also used to compare ScO 2 in children who died with that in survivors.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Mean baseline ScO 2 was 59% (range, 26% to 86%, Table 1) for the entire cohort. Neonates with ductus-dependent circulation had a baseline ScO 2 of 57% (range, 48% to 71%); baseline was 61% in group P1, and 55% in group R (p = NS). Baseline ScO 2 was lowest in infants who had already completed initial palliation: 41% in group I and 42% in group P2. Children presenting for completion Fontan (group P3) had normal baseline ScO 2 (mean, 70%) despite their cyanosis (Table 1).
Cerebral oxygen saturation increased on bypass in all groups (Fig 2), as has been previously reported [2, 4]. After bypass, neonates in group R had a slightly improved ScO 2 (Fig 2), but ScO 2 was slightly lower than preoperatively in group P1. Neither of these changes reached statistical significance. The group P2 infants were the only ones in which there was a significant improvement in ScO 2 immediately after CPB, to 53% (p = 0.04). Normal ScO 2 was maintained in children undergoing completion Fontan. Cerebral oxygen saturation was not affected by modified ultrafiltration (Fig 2). By the time infants in group P1 had left the operating room, however, a significant decrease had occurred in ScO 2 to 48% (p = 0.001). There was no significant change from baseline in the other groups (Table 1), although there was a trend toward a higher ScO 2 in group P3 (p = 0.08).
|
|
|
|
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this study, we set out to evaluate the relationship between the stage of repair (physiology) and ScO 2 in children with single ventricle congenital heart disease. These children have significant changes in cardiovascular physiology as staged palliation is accomplished. Neonates with ductus-dependent circulation have a physiology that is characterized by mixing of oxygenated and deoxygenated blood (cyanosis) as well as significant pulmonary overcirculation with its attendant volume load on the heart. In cases in which complete repair is possible, postoperative physiology is "normal" (that is, no left-to-right shunt and no mixing or cyanosis), but infants undergoing stage 1 palliation are left with the same physiologic abnormalities, plus those added by surgery and CPB. Even when the right ventriclepulmonary artery conduit is used, the pulmonarysystemic flow ratio remains significantly higher than 1:1.
Stage 2 palliation is designed to get rid of the pulmonary overcirculation, but the child is left with the physiology of mixing and now has an added resistance load on the single ventricle.
Finally, after the Fontan, the child has no mixing, no cyanosis, and no extra volume load on the heart, but the single ventricle faces the physiologic challenge of pumping against two serial resistance circuits.
We have shown that ScO 2, measured in the operating room, is related to the stage of palliation (the cardiovascular physiology). Baseline ScO 2 for various congenital heart defects has been previously reported by us [12] and others [2]. This study has specifically evaluated the changes in ScO 2 during the various stages of single ventricle palliation.
Neonates with ductus-dependent circulation have, on average, a lower-than-normal ScO 2, but this difference does not reach significance in this small study. These infants are struggling with a physiology of high cardiac output and high pulmonary blood flow. After bypass, ScO 2 is higher in repaired infants (group R), but it trends downward in those who are palliated (group P1); at the conclusion of surgery, ScO 2 was significantly lower than baseline in group P1. This most likely reflects the underlying physiology, which has been corrected only in the first group.
Low ScO 2 has been previously reported in neonates after Norwood palliation [13]. Infants undergoing stage 1 palliation are left with both cyanosis from mixing and leftright shunt physiology, which results in a combination of lower arterial and lower mixed venous oxygen saturation, both contributing to decrease ScO 2. Initial palliation may limit pulmonary blood flow but does not alter the underlying physiology. It might therefore be expected to stabilizebut not greatly "improve"systemic perfusion and ScO 2, relative to the infant with an open ductus arteriosus.
Group I infants had the lowest baseline ScO 2 of the cohort. We may be able to explain this from their physiology: a combination of the inherently inefficient stage 1 physiology that is now exacerbated by progressive systemic cyanosis. Infants presenting for stage 2 palliation similarly had relatively low baseline ScO 2. Group I infants were subjected to the stress of a second palliative operation that did not change their underlying physiology of high cardiac output, elevated pulmonary blood flow, and mixing, so it may come as no surprise that their ScO 2 did not improve postoperatively, despite an improvement in the arterial partial pressure of oxygen (Table 2). Similarly, it is this group that had the highest mortality.
Although infants undergoing stage 2 palliation often do not have any improvement in systemic oxygen saturation after surgery, we might expect their ScO 2 to be higher postoperatively owing to the improved physiology (with resultant higher mixed venous saturation). Our data support this assessment of the physiology: Group P2 infants left the operating room with ScO 2 significantly higher than baseline, despite no significant differences in arterial oxygen saturation, central venous pressure, or hematocrit. This is especially noteworthy when one considers that these values are measured shortly after CPB, at which time the infant would be expected to have some degree of bypass-related decrement in oxygenation; the data may therefore under-represent the patients actual stage 2 physiology. This hypothesis is supported by the fact that ScO 2 improves over time and normalizes before the Fontan.
Children undergoing completion Fontan had normal ScO 2 before, during, and after surgery, with a trend towards higher saturation at the end of the operation, possibly reflecting the higher systemic oxygen saturation.
We did not demonstrate a relationship between perioperative CNS complications and low ScO 2. This is partly related to the size of the study but may also be influenced by the fact that ScO 2 was used as a clinical tool in our patients and every effort was made to optimize it. Perioperative neurologic injury, therefore, resulted from causes unrecognized by our monitoring (ScO 2 was normal) or from physiologic problems that we were unable to rectify. It is important to emphasize that neurologic complications can and do occur in patients with normal ScO 2 and that monitoring a normal ScO 2 should not be taken as assurance that no CNS complications will occur.
The overall perioperative mortality in our study was 11%, with the highest mortality in the patients undergoing interstage operations (25%) and those undergoing stage 1 palliation for hypoplastic left heart syndrome (22%). These results are comparable with recent studies of single ventricle palliation in similarly sized programs [1418]. We have previously demonstrated that an abnormally low baseline ScO 2 is predictive of perioperative death in a larger cohort of children undergoing repairs for congenital heart disease [12]. In the current smaller study we were able to demonstrate a strong correlation between low postrepair ScO 2 and perioperative death. Presumably this correlation would have been even stronger had we made no attempt to correct the low ScO 2.
In most of our patients, ScO 2 is most likely a surrogate marker for systemic perfusion; it has been shown elsewhere [7] to correlate with mixed venous oxygen saturation in children undergoing cardiac surgery. Continuous monitoring of ScO 2, like mixed venous oxygen saturation allows early recognition of the fact that "something" is wrong and permits early intervention.
The significant drop in ScO 2 after initial palliation is especially concerning in view of the high mortality rate between the first and second stages of single ventricle palliation [15, 19, 20]. It may very well be that patients who leave the operating room, the intensive care unit, or the hospital with low ScO 2 are at higher risk of interim death. It may also be that monitoring ScO 2 intermittently on an outpatient basis may allow earlier detection, and thus correction, of physiologic problems.
Limitations of our study include its small size and generally retrospective design. The hemodynamic data from the patients preoperative cardiac catheterization was temporally too far removed from the operation to provide usable data. Similarly, it would be helpful to report hematocrit and systemic arterial oxygen saturation values sampled at the same time as the ScO 2, but we are unable to exactly correlate the timing of the respective samples. Another limitation is that it does not include all of the patients who underwent surgery during the study period because the oximeter was at first used only sporadically.
A longitudinal study, with evaluation of the same patient population progressing through staged palliation, may have provided additional information but would have had the disadvantage of magnifying the effects of changes in practice pattern over time. Finally, although we determined that ductus-dependent neonates undergoing a complete two-ventricle repair made a good comparison group for those undergoing initial palliation, we were unable to find satisfactory "control" groups for stages 2 and 3.
Future work in this area might include the use of ScO 2 measurement to better evaluate how to optimize physiology in patients during and after initial palliation. For example, how does use of the Sano modification affect cerebral oxygenation, and what is the optimum conduit size? Will monitoring ScO 2 after surgery, in the intensive care unit or sporadically on an outpatient basis, allow detection of problems with a resultant improvement in outcome? It might also be interesting to attempt to correlate ScO 2 with more subtle neurologic abnormalities by formal neurologic evaluation.
In conclusion, we have demonstrated that initial palliation of single ventricle congenital heart disease results in a significant decrease in ScO 2 that is not seen in neonates undergoing complete two-ventricle repair. This low ScO 2 persists over time (stage 2 infants have the lowest baseline ScO 2) and we speculate that it may correlate with interim mortality. Low postoperative ScO 2 is related to perioperative mortality in children undergoing palliation of single ventricle congenital heart disease.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Related Article
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. D. Kurth, J. C. McCann, J. Wu, L. Miles, and A. W. Loepke Cerebral Oxygen Saturation-Time Threshold for Hypoxic-Ischemic Injury in Piglets Anesth. Analg., April 1, 2009; 108(4): 1268 - 1277. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. C. Hirsch, J. R. Charpie, R. G. Ohye, and J. G. Gurney Near-infrared spectroscopy: What we know and what we need to know--A systematic review of the congenital heart disease literature J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., January 1, 2009; 137(1): 154 - 159. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Delius Invited commentary Ann. Thorac. Surg., April 1, 2007; 83(4): 1436 - 1437. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |