|
|
||||||||
Ann Thorac Surg 1999;68:479-485
© 1999 The Society of Thoracic Surgeons
a Cohesion Technologies, Palo Alto, California, USA
Address reprint requests to Dr Prior, Cohesion Technologies, Inc, 2500 Faber Place, Palo Alto, CA 94303
e-mail: jprior{at}cson.com
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods. Hemostatic performance was determined with an in vivo bleeding rabbit kidney and spleen model. Differential scanning calorimetry and electron microscopy were used to analyze collagen structure. Sealing ability was determined with a burst-test apparatus.
Results. In the in vivo model, CoStasis was superior to fibrin sealant and collagen sponges in achieving a rapid time to hemostasis. The formulation continued to perform well when either platelets or fibrinogen was depleted. CoStasis formed weaker gels than fibrin sealant and could withstand only modest pressures. The collagen in the formulation had a fibrillar structure that was shown to aggregate human platelets.
Conclusions. CoStasis, with the two platelet activators collagen and thrombin in addition to the thrombin-catalyzed formation of fibrin and the sealing properties of the soft gel, provides an excellent atraumatic hemostat.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this report, we describe the in vivo hemostatic performance of CoStasis in a bleeding rabbit kidney and spleen model, where the time to hemostasis after application of CoStasis was compared with the time to hemostasis after using Instat collagen sponge, an investigational fibrin sealant, and Tisseel commercial fibrin sealant. In the kidney model, the superior performance of CoStasis is demonstrated. The physical and chemical characteristics of CoStasis are described, and the collagen components activity in platelet aggregation is demonstrated.
| Material and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Plasma was obtained for in vivo experiments by centrifuging fresh citrated rabbit blood (0.32% sodium citrate, wt/vol) at 1,380 g for 2 minutes to yield platelet-rich plasma. Rabbit plasma contains approximately 2 mg of fibrinogen per milliliter [4]. For in vivo experiments testing depleted plasma, platelet-rich plasma was spun at 1,380 g for 45 minutes to yield platelet-poor plasma. Platelet depletion was verified by hemocytometer count to give a reduction of 98.4% in the platelet-poor plasma. The two preparations were mixed 1:1 to yield platelets at 50% of normal levels. Fibrinogen-depleted plasma was made as follows: platelet-poor plasma was made as just described, and the platelet pellet was saved to be mixed with the plasma after removal of the fibrinogen. Fibrinogen was precipitated out of the plasma by heating to 53° to 56°C for 3 minutes as previously described [5]. After the fibrinogen was pelletted, the fibrinogen-depleted supernatant was mixed with platelets as needed. The fibrinogen-depleted plasma was mixed with normal plasma to yield plasma at 50% of normal levels. Fibrinogen levels were determined using a BBL fibrometer (Becton Dickinson, Cockeysville, MD) by the method described in procedure No. 880, Sigma Diagnostics (St. Louis, MO). Fibrinogen levels were 300 to 330 mg/dL in normal rabbit plasma, 150 mg/dL in the 50%-depleted plasma, and not measurable in the fibrinogen-depleted plasma.
The investigational fibrin sealant was prepared from reagents supplied by Haemacure (Kirkland, PQ, Canada). Tisseel was from Immuno, AG (Vienna, Austria). Human fibrinogen was used at concentrations of 60 or 125 mg/mL. Clotting of the fibrinogen was achieved by rapid mixing with an equal volume of solution containing either 160 U/mL of human thrombin or 500 U/mL of bovine thrombin in 40 mmol/L CaCl2. Instat collagen sponge was from Johnson & Johnson (Arlington, TX). Fibrin sealant and CoStasis were applied using a two-syringe system, which allowed the thrombin-containing syringe and the fibrinogen-containing syringe to be depressed simultaneously and the fluids mixed through a Y connector and sprayed on the bleeding site.
In vivo rabbit hemostasis model
Adult New Zealand White rabbits were anesthetized with an intramuscular injection of ketamine hydrochloride (35 mg/kg) and xylazine hydrochloride (3 mg/kg). Anesthesia was maintained during the procedure by inhalation of isoflurane and oxygen. The abdomen was shaved, and a midline laparotomy was performed to expose the viscera. An incision 2 mm deep by 15 mm long was made in the kidney and in the spleen. Gauze was used to lightly wipe up the blood for approximately 3 to 5 seconds immediately after the incision was made and was then removed just prior to application of the test material. The light pressure on the gauze was applied by the same individual in the same manner for all treatments. The time interval from application of material until hemostasis was reached was determined. Animals received humane care in compliance with the "Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals" published by the National Institutes of Health (NIH publication 85-23, revised 1985).
Statistical analyses of mean times to hemostasis were performed using Wilcoxon sign rank tests of time-to-event data in a Kaplan-Meier analysis to determine p values. Observations of time to hemostasis exceeding 10 minutes were censored and included as 10 minutes for the purpose of these analyses. All analyses were performed using JMP version 3.0 (SAS Institute).
Electron microscopy
For electron microscopy, component 1 of CoStasis (collagen plus thrombin) was diluted 1:100, 1:1000, and 1:10000 on ice. Drops of sample were placed on Parafilm in a Petri dish and kept on ice. Butvar/carboncoated grids were floated on top of the drops of sample for 15 minutes. Grids were wicked with filter paper, allowed to dry, and then placed sample side down on beads of 1% phosphotungstic acid (pH 7.0) for 10 minutes. Grids were wicked dry and viewed on a Philips CM10 transmission electron microscope operating at 80 kV.
Differential scanning calorimetry
Differential scanning calorimetry was performed on a Mettler DSC 20 and TC10 TA processor (Hightstown, NJ). Samples containing 0.1 to 0.3 mg of collagen in approximately 12 to 15 µL were sealed in aluminum pans and heated at 10°C per minute. A reference pan containing only buffer was prepared and heated at the same time in the instrument.
Rheometry
Rheometry was performed in a Rheometrics fluids spectrometer (model 8400; Piscataway, NJ) using parallel- plate geometry. CoStasis was prepared as already described except the plasma component was acidified to pH 5.0, which prevented gelation and allowed time for degassing and loading the sample. The sample was then submerged in neutral phosphate buffer, and the time course of gelation was monitored. The dynamic elastic modulus, or G', was measured at an oscillation rate of 1 radian/s and a strain of 1% [6]. The gelled sample was then exposed to a frequency sweep (oscillation rate, 0.1 to 100 radian/s) and a strain sweep (strain, 1% to 50%). Two control formulations were also prepared; one, called thrombin-plasma, had the collagen omitted from the composition just described, and the other, called collagen-plasma, contained collagen and plasma but no thrombin or calcium. Finally, the rheometry of a fibrin sealant was examined. In this case, gelation was delayed by using a low concentration of thrombin (6 U/mL).
Platelet aggregation
Platelet aggregation was performed with a Sienco dual sample aggregation meter (Morrison, CO). Platelet-rich plasma was isolated by centrifuging blood from human donors for 2 minutes at 1,380 g. The platelet-rich plasma was mixed with fibrillar collagen, and the time required to reach one half of the maximum aggregation was determined for each sample and used as a measure of platelet-aggregating ability. Statistical analysis of the time required to reach half of the maximum aggregation was by analysis of variance using a Tukey-Kramer analysis of all data pairs.
Burst tests
Burst tests were performed on a custom apparatus that consisted of a pressure gauge (model PG5000; PSI-Tronix, Tulare, CA) connected to a circular sample plate with a central orifice 2 mm in diameter. To simulate a tissue surface, the sample plate had a circular sheet of coarse-fibered collagen, prepared from pulverized cow hide, and a matching central hole, fastened to it by a gasket seal. After the collagen sheet was dampened with saline solution, the test formulation was sprayed onto the surface to seal the hole. Pressurized saline solution was then applied by a syringe pump (Sage Instruments model 355; Orion Research, Cambridge, MA) at a flow rate of 5 mL/min, and the pressure at which saline solution penetrated the test formulation was recorded.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
0.05, Wilcoxon) than the other materials. In the spleen, CoStasis again was found to have significantly shorter bleeding times (p
0.05, Wilcoxon) than the other formulations (Table 2). The fibrin sealant, which contained lower levels of fibrinogen and thrombin, achieved hemostasis in less than half of the sites treated, and therefore a median time to hemostasis could not be calculated. The mean was calculated using a value of 10 minutes for the data exceeding the 10-minute cutoff time.
|
|
On kidney sites when platelets were depleted by 50%, the hemostatic performance was equivalent to that using plasma with normal platelet levels (Table 3, experiments 1 and 2). Although not significantly different, the hemostatic performance using plasma with 100%-depleted platelets was slower than that using normal plasma (see Table 3, experiment 3). Both the 50%-depleted and completely platelet-depleted plasmas achieved hemostasis in all the kidney sites in less than 2 minutes, a significantly greater proportion than with Instat (p
0.04, Wilcoxon).
|
When both platelets and fibrinogen were depleted, the mean time to hemostasis was significantly slower than when normal plasma was used (p = 0.001, Wilcoxon) and not significantly different from the mean time with Instat (see Table 3, experiment 6). The depleted plasma achieved hemostasis in only 30% of kidney sites versus 100% with normal plasma. When platelets were completely depleted but fibrinogen was only 50% depleted, the time to hemostasis was still significantly slower than normal (p < 0.04) and not significantly different from that of Instat (see Table 3, experiment 7). In this case, hemostasis was achieved in 70% of the sites, intermediate between the completely depleted and normal values.
Material consisting of the collagen and thrombin component alone, without plasma, was also tested (see Table 3, experiment 8). This material had a hemostatic performance significantly slower than that of the normal formulation (p < 0.0005, Wilcoxon) but not significantly different from that of Instat.
The data for hemostatic performance in the spleen are presented in Table 4. Because these data were highly variable, none of the values were significantly different. However, depletion of platelets and fibrinogen generally correlated with a decrease in the percentage of sites achieving hemostasis in 10 minutes or less and an increase in mean time to hemostasis. The poorest-performing materials in the spleen were the formulation with complete depletion of platelets and the formulation with no plasma component. In both of these cases, only 20% of the sites achieved hemostasis in less than or equal to 10 minutes, and the average time to hemostasis increased to greater than 500 seconds. The variability of the spleen data is also apparent when it is noted that the increase in mean time to hemostasis for CoStasis made with normal plasma in this experiment is longer than the mean time for CoStasis and Instat from the previous experiment (see Table 2).
|
|
Because thrombin is a strong platelet-aggregating agent [9], it was used as a positive control to verify that the collagen was fully aggregating platelets. At 0.2 U/mL (sufficient to activate platelets, binding both high and moderate affinity receptors [10]), the degree of platelet aggregation was similar to that of the CoStasis collagen.
Physical characterization of CoStasis gel
Rheometry was used to follow the gelling response and the strength (as determined by the G' [11]) of the final gel at 25°C. The strengths of a fibrin sealant, CoStasis, a thrombin-plasma gel (lacking collagen), and a collagen-plasma gel (without thrombin or calcium) were compared. As seen in Table 5, CoStasis formed a stronger gel than the thrombin-plasma gel and the collagen-plasma gel; the CoStasis gel and the thrombin-plasma gel were resistant to strain. Fibrin sealant, with much higher fibrinogen levels, formed gels three orders of magnitude higher in G' compared with CoStasis and also resistant to strain.
|
|
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Here we used a formulation containing fibrillar collagen in suspension with thrombin and calcium chloride and mixed with the patients platelet-rich plasma. CoStasis was compared with Tisseel fibrin sealant, currently used in Europe for hemostasis, with Instat collagen sponge, used in the United States as a hemostat, and with an investigational fibrin sealant. The bleeding kidney model data demonstrated that CoStasis achieved hemostasis significantly faster than fibrin sealant and Instat; the spleen data were more variable and therefore inconclusive. CoStasis was the only material to achieve hemostasis in all of the kidneys in less than 2 minutes, our goal for a fast-acting hemostat.
The use of plasma as the fibrinogen component of a fibrin sealant, or fibrin gel, has been investigated by previous workers who compared it with fibrin glue from cryoprecipitate. Oz and colleagues [15] made a fibrin gel from platelet-rich plasma and 500 U/mL of thrombin and in a bleeding rabbit liver and spleen model, found no significant difference in hemostasis between it and cryoprecipitate-prepared fibrin glue. Hartman and co-workers [16] used the patients plasma to make fibrin gel at operation and reported that it provided hemostasis that was at least as good as that of heterologous plasma glue in 40 cardiac surgical patients; postoperative chest tube outputs were similar, with a trend toward less output when the patients own plasma was used.
Because the fibrinogen is from the patients own plasma (prepared with a sterile plasma collection system, supplied by the manufacturer, in about 5 minutes), CoStasis addresses the risk of hepatitis, acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, and other transmissible disease agents in blood. CoStasis provides a superior hemostat without the risks associated with fibrin sealants derived from pooled human blood (although these risks are reduced with Tisseel which is treated to inactivate viruses).
CoStasis was found to remain effective when either platelets or fibrinogen were depleted by 50%. Even at 100% depletion of either component, hemostasis in each kidney tested was achieved in less than 2 minutes. It was only in experiments where both fibrinogen and platelets were depleted that significantly slower times to hemostasis were observed, although not significantly different from those of the Instat collagen sponge. The data suggest that, compared with currently available hemostats, CoStasis should perform well in patients with low levels of fibrinogen or platelets.
When the collagen in CoStasis was tested for platelet aggregation, the activity did not decrease until the collagen concentration was less than 0.05 mg/mL. The collagen in the CoStasis product is 10 mg/mL when it is delivered to the bleeding site, thus assuring the presence of ample collagen to aggregate platelets. CoStasis also contains 250 U/mL of thrombin, one of the strongest platelet aggregators [10]; thus, the CoStasis formulation benefits from two powerful platelet aggregators that, at the bleeding site, causes the formation of a platelet a plug, which releases coagulation factors, and provides a procoagulant surface.
CoStasis formed a gel with a higher G' than corresponding gels made when collagen was absent (thrombin-plasma). Further, the CoStasis G' was greater than the sum of the moduli of the collagen gel alone and the thrombin-plasma gel. The latter observation suggests that collagen and fibrin networks have a synergistic effect on each other, as noted previously [1]. The fact that fibrin sealant exhibited a much higher G' value implies that a hard gel is not necessarily better. This has been observed by Basu and coworkers [17], who found that fibrin sealant made from cryoprecipitate was as effective in controlling bleeding from aortic and atrial suture lines and from the epicardium as a commercial fibrin sealant (130 mg/mL of protein concentrate) in a canine model.
Burst data demonstrated that CoStasis and plasma gels had lower burst strengths than fibrin sealant, which is consistent with the other results described. In addition, the burst pressure of CoStasis was lower than capillary blood pressure (25 mm Hg) [18]. This finding implies that the mechanism of hemostatic action by CoStasis is not simply to seal over a wound; rather, the collagen-strengthened gel adheres to the bleeding site and thus provides some tamponade hemostatic effect; as blood migrates into the gel, thrombin is present to catalyze fibrin clot formation, and collagen and thrombin initiate platelet activation and aggregation.
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| Footnotes |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. G. Schoenecker, R. K. Johnson, A. P. Lesher, J. D. Day, S. D. Love, M. R. Hoffman, T. L. Ortel, W. Parker, and J. H. Lawson Exposure of Mice to Topical Bovine Thrombin Induces Systemic Autoimmunity Am. J. Pathol., November 1, 2001; 159(5): 1957 - 1969. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |